Just Be Yourself Is Terrible Advice

Why following your heart can leave you empty, and what Jesus says to do instead.

Jun 10, 2025

Hey, I’m Pastor Chris — a guy who’s tried too hard to be himself and still came up short. This space is for people who are done pretending and just want to follow Jesus for real. If that’s you, subscribe or send a coffee. Let’s grow together. Honest, flawed, and fully His.

I was probably 13 or 14 — caught in that awkward space where your voice cracks but your dreams don't. Our Youth Pastor had this wild idea: hand the mic to the students. No notes. No coaching. Just come up and preach.

Naturally, I thought, “I got this.”

I was hooked because I had just watched a famous TV preacher light up a stadium. The way he spoke—bold and fiery, people leaning in, hands raised—I wanted that. I took notes like my life depended on it—verse after verse, point after point. I came to the youth group ready to set the room on fire.

And then... it was my turn.

I stood before everyone, including the high schoolers who looked like they bench-pressed middle schoolers for fun, and delivered my message. Every line I thought would land just... floated. Every verse I thought would stir hearts barely stirred air.

No one leaned in, and no one looked changed. For the first time in my youth, I felt the quiet sting of doing something with all my heart and watching it fall flat.

I wasn’t faking it. I believed what I was saying.

But the truth?

My heart was in it, but my time hadn’t come yet.

And maybe, just maybe, 13-year-old me was trying to imitate someone else’s fire instead of carrying my own.

Looking back, I wasn’t trying to be fake — I was just trying to be impressive.

But imitation isn’t identity.

And sometimes “just being yourself” is being someone you admire, hoping it works.

That moment taught me something I’ve never forgotten:

You can be passionate, sincere, and still perform.

Real identity doesn’t come from mimicking someone else’s voice. It comes from following Jesus until you find your own.

Peter Was Just Being Himself

Peter was a hot mess with a good heart.

Loud. Loyal. Zero chill.

If anyone was “just being himself,” it was Peter. The guy who swore he’d never walk away from Jesus, then denied Him to a middle school girl and ran.

It wrecked him.

He wept bitterly, not because he broke the rules, but because he broke the relationship.

Because his most authentic moment of being “real” and self-protective exposed what was still broken in him.

That’s the part nobody talks about when they say, “Just be yourself.”

Why This Lie Sounds So Good

“Just be yourself” is on T-shirts, Instagram bios, and probably a coffee mug you no longer use.

It’s the theme of graduation speeches, Disney movies, and every influencer who sells candles and coaching in the same post.

And I get it.

The idea is simple: Don’t fake it. Don’t perform. Be real.

We need that kind of honesty in the Church.

But here’s where it gets dangerous — when we start equating self-expression with salvation.

When we think that finding our truth is the same as following the truth,

I grew up hearing that cliché: “If you do what you love, you’ll never work a day in your life.”

It sounded wise and motivational, like something you'd find on a coffee mug or a Pinterest quote board.

But here’s what I’ve learned the hard way: doing what you love without being ready can quickly burn you out.

I chased roles I wasn’t built for in my early years.

I tried to carve out a platform, start a ministry, launch something big — all before the roots were deep enough to hold the weight. And I see that same hunger in others today: sincere people pushing open doors God hasn’t unlocked, wondering why it all feels so empty.

But when someone spends time with the Father, and the time is NOW, you can feel the difference.

Doors swing open that man couldn’t have kicked down.
Opportunities find them.
And what they carry isn’t just ambition — it’s anointing.

Because calling isn’t something you grab.

It’s something you receive.

The Cracks in the Foundation

The Bible doesn’t tell you to “be yourself.”

It says things like:

“The heart is deceitful above all things…” (Jeremiah 17:9)
“Deny yourself. Take up your cross. Follow Me.” (Luke 9:23)

Not exactly coffee mug material.

Peter followed his gut. His passion. His instincts. And they led him to a fire pit where he swore he didn’t even know Jesus.

That’s what being yourself gets you when your identity isn’t anchored in Christ.

Sometimes “your truth” will straight-up lie to you.

And sometimes, God’s truth will offend the version of you you still hold onto.

What Jesus Actually Says

Jesus didn’t cancel Peter.

He didn’t hand him a journal and say, “Take time to rediscover yourself.”

He cooked him breakfast.

Then He asked him three questions:

“Do you love Me?”
“Then feed My sheep.” (John 21)

He didn’t say “stay true to who you are.”

He said, “Follow Me.”

That’s the invitation.

Not to build a better version of ourselves, but to die to ourselves so we can actually live.

I’m creative, and I regularly have the urge to build things, write things, worship through music, and occasionally blow up monsters in a video game. I can sit and forget about everything else for a while.

It’s calming, but it can take up too much of my time if I'm not careful.

Lately, we’ve been in a season where the hobbies I once enjoyed are on hold—maybe indefinitely. We pared down our belongings and drove about a thousand miles to move to a new state.

This season, I’m learning that I don’t have to do something every minute to relax. I’m free to do other things without certain hobbies clouding my mind. While my pastimes are good, there’s peace at the other end of obedience.

There’s a Better Way to Live

Jesus doesn’t want to improve the unhealed version of you.

He wants to remake you from the inside out.

“If anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation. The old has passed away; behold, the new has come.” (2 Corinthians 5:17)

You are not:

Your personality type
Your trauma
Your calling
Your screw-ups

You are who He says you are.

And that identity isn’t based on emotion. It’s rooted in resurrection.

The Lies I Used To Believe

I will always struggle
No one will ever see my worth
I have nothing valuable to give
Things will never change

What God Replaced Those Lies With:

I am a son of the Most High King. I have everything I need.
My Heavenly Father sees my worth, and He’s proud of me.
I am gifted with talents from my Father, and I carry a more valuable message than anything this world can offer.
My Father will open doors that no man can open, and no man can shut.

How to Break the Lie

Want to live free?

Start here:

1. Name the version of “yourself” you’ve been clinging to.
Maybe it’s the sarcastic one. The put-together one. The tough one. The one that never lets anyone in.

2. Lay it down.
Let it die. Jesus doesn’t build on pride or posturing. He builds on surrender.

3. Let God tell you who you are.
Open the Word. Ask Him. Let His voice get louder than your feelings.

Final Word

“Just be yourself” will get you applause.
But “follow Me” will get you healed.

And if that feels hard, you’re not alone.
I’m still learning to lay down the version of me that looks strong but isn’t surrendered.

And every time I do?

He meets me at the fire.
He feeds me grace.
He gives me purpose again.

Let’s Talk About It

If something in this article resonated with you, I’d love to hear about it. Drop a comment and share your story — the questions, the struggles, the moments where God met you. You never know who might need to hear it, too.